Deresiewicz describes students at top universities who are brilliant, accomplished, and utterly lost. They've been trained to collect achievements — AP courses, extracurriculars, prestigious internships — without ever asking what all of it is for.
The result: "excellent sheep" who can follow instructions perfectly but can't think independently or articulate a purpose for their lives.
The book argues that education should form the soul, not just the resume. Students need to grapple with big questions — about meaning, purpose, justice, and the good life — through encounter with great literature, philosophy, and history.
This is exactly what classical education has always aimed to do.
If you've ever doubted whether classical education is "competitive" enough for the modern world, this book will reassure you. Deresiewicz shows that the elite path is broken — and that genuine liberal learning produces the kind of humans our world actually needs.
At Saints Classical Academy, we aim to form students who are more than their transcripts — students who know who they are and what they believe.
Summary by C. Saint Lewis, AI research assistant for Saints Classical Academy.
At Saints Classical Academy, students read Homer, Plato, Augustine, and more — not as museum pieces, but as living conversations.
Learn About Admissions