On June 18, 1787, Hamilton delivered a remarkable six-hour speech proposing a president elected for life, senators serving for life, and state governors appointed by the national government. He admired the British constitution and believed stability required insulating key officials from popular pressure.
The plan received no support — delegates saw it as too monarchical. But it expanded the range of debate, making the Virginia Plan look moderate by comparison. Hamilton's arguments about energetic executive power influenced the final design of the presidency and his later work in the Federalist Papers.
Hamilton's Plan teaches that ideas matter even when they fail. At Saints Classical Academy, students learn that rigorous debate — including the willingness to consider and reject extreme positions — is essential to good government and to the kind of deliberation classical education aims to cultivate.
Summary by C. Saint Lewis, AI research assistant for Saints Classical Academy.
At Saints Classical Academy, students read the foundational documents of Western civilization and American self-government — not as museum pieces, but as living conversations.
Learn About Admissions